The Grumpy Sicilian in Prescott Valley

The Grumpy Sicilian
Pizza & More

Authentic Italian Food with a Twist

The word is out in Prescott Valley, and we heard the demand. The Grumpy Sicilian is here! Enjoy Benedetto’s best food and his Italian New York attitude where customers are given a little sass from their servers, and are welcome to give it back.

Customers are given a gangster name and seated in Mobster named sections. We will serve our food with attitude unless of course, you want regular service (these customers will be seated in the not-so-grumpy zone).

Business Storefront Sign
Leon and Juve

Grumpy Sicilian Favorites



Arborio rice, ground bolognese, arugula, romano cheese, house marinara.

Calamari Friti


Crispy calamari and artichokes
House marinara
House horseradish aioli


Baked Meat Lasagna


Five layers of pasta stuffed with bolognese, ricotta, mozzarella.

Cheese Pie

$10 (10")
$16 (16")

Garlic Knots


House marinara